Just a place to jot down my musings.

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

“Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge?”

From the Choruses of TS Eliot’s The Rock:

The Eagle soars in the summit of Heaven,
The Hunter with his dogs pursues his circuit.

O perpetual revolution of configured stars,
O perpetual recurrence of determined seasons,
O world of spring and autumn, birth and dying!

The endless cycle of idea and action,
Endless invention, endless experiment,
Brings knowledge of motion, but not of stillness;
Knowledge of speech, but not of silence;
Knowledge of words, and ignorance of the Word.

All our knowledge brings us nearer to death,
But nearness to death no nearer to God.

Where is the Life we have lost in living?

Where is the wisdom we have lost in knowledge?

Where is the knowledge we have lost in information?

The cycles of Heaven in twenty centuries
Brings us farther from God and nearer to the Dust.


Thursday, May 31, 2012

“The Splendor of the Great Hero”: Śrī Raghuvīra Gadyam aka Śrī Mahāvīra Vaibhavam

Among the most remarkable compositions of Swami Śrīman Nigamānta Mahādeśikar is the Śrī Mahāvīra Vaibhavam, also known as the Raghuvīra Gadyam. In about 90 lines, it summarizes the entire story of the Rāmāyaṇa, paying special attention to the glory and heroism of Rāma. I have attempted to translate the work here while paying close attention to the poetic effects of the original.

|| Śrīḥ  ||

śrīmān veṅkaṭanāthâryaḥ kavi-tārkika-kesarī |
vedāntâcārya-varyo me sannidhattāṃ sadā hṛdi ||

The noble Veṅkaṭanātha,
endowed with śrī,
saffron-maned Lion among poets and philosophers,
supreme teacher of the Vedānta
—may he be established forever in my heart!

jayaty āśrita-saṃtrāsa-dhvānta-vidhvaṃsanôdayaḥ |
prabhāvān sītayā devyā parama-vyoma-bhāskaraḥ ||

He conquers all,
His dawn dispelling the darkness of His devotees’ dread;
Luminous,
Inseparable from the Goddess Sītā, 
The Sun of the Supreme Heaven!

jaya jaya mahāvīra! 
mahādhīra dhaureya! 

Victory, victory to the great hero! 
to the steadfast, resolute, bearer of all burdens!


Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Appayya Dīkṣita on rūpaka (“metaphor”)

Among the works of the great 16th century savant Appayya Dīkṣita is the Kuvalayānanda (“Joy of the Water-lily”), which became the standard introductory textbook on figures of speech throughout India, particularly in the South. The Kuvalayānanda focuses entirely on arthâlaṅkāras, “ornaments of meaning”. My non-existent knowledge of Western rhetoric prevents me from translating the term precisely, but I suspect it may correspond to trope.

Prof. Yigal Bronner has a series of articles on Appayya Dīkṣita’s prodigious œuvre in literary theory, of which “Back to the Future: Appayya Diksita's Kuvalayananda and the Rewriting of Sanskrit Poetics” describes the structure of the Kuvalayānanda. Specifically, the text is organized in three layers: (1) kārikās, around 170 easily memorizable verses in the anuṣṭubh meter that define and exemplify exactly 100 alaṅkāras; (2) examples of these alaṅkāras drawn from kāvya; and (3) an auto-commentary of sorts, in which Appayya Dīkṣita explains his motivation for defining the alaṅkāra in that fashion and sets it into its context of over a millennium of alaṅkāra-śāstra. I shall draw solely from layer (1), the kārikās, here.

For now, I want to focus on just one trope, rūpaka, usually translated “metaphor”. Its definition takes up one verse; examples of its subtypes each take up half a verse. I’m not going to translate the definition literally, because the compactness of Sanskrit technical writing does not render well in English. In what follows, [the stuff inside brackets] isn’t part of the Kuvalayānanda itself.

[rūpakam]

viṣayayy-abheda-tādrūpya-rañjanaṃ viṣayasya yat |
rūpakaṃ tat tridhâdhikya-nyūnatvânubhayôktibhiḥ ||


Sunday, May 27, 2012

Counting, uncounting, and dust, part seven

The word “dust” has appeared in the title of every post in this series, and we will finally begin to see why. Many counterintuitive marvels remain to be unmasked in the counterintuitive worlds of cardinality and measure theory. Georg Ferdinand Ludwig Philipp Cantor, the mathematician who laid the foundations for the modern understanding of infinity, was responsible for the discovery of some of these truly unbelievable marvels.

There seems to be a whole sub-genre of math blog posts that focus on defining or presenting the Cantor set at different levels of rigor! For our purposes, I will offer two descriptions (without proof). 
  • The Cantor set can be described quite “simply” as the set of all real numbers between 0 and 1 whose ternary representation contains only 0 and 2. (We use the decimal place value system in everyday life, while computers use the binary, using only 0 and 1.) The ternary place value system uses 0, 1, and 2 as the only digits. So the number 0.1 in ternary represents the fraction \( \frac{1}{3} \), and 0.22 the fraction \( \frac{8}{9} \), and so on. It is also worth noting that just as we take the decimal 0.999… to be equal to the number 1, we must also take the ternary number 0.0222… to be equal to the ternary number 0.1, and so on.
  • The Cantor set can also be seen as the limit of an infinite process of cutting up the closed interval \( [0, 1] \). The rule is simple: at every stage, delete the middle third (excluding the endpoints) of every remaining interval. Repeat ad infinitum. The first few stages of such a process are shown in this picture.
How does the Cantor set measure up (pun intended) using our four different definitions of size?



Counting, uncounting, and dust, part six


Let’s quickly recap of some of the interesting things we have seen so far.
  • The real numbers are uncountable, and in fact every interval of the real numbers is uncountable. In other words, there are more real numbers between 0 and 1 than there are integers from negative infinity to positive infinity. 
    • However, this alone does not really give us a sense of just how much bigger uncountable is than countable. For instance, we can see that the sequence of fractional numbers \( \{ 1, \frac{1}{2}, \frac{1}{3}, \frac{1}{4}, \ldots \} \) is also contained within the interval \( (0, 1) \). It is clear, though, that this sequence has the cardinality of \( \mathbb{N} \). It is thus not really clear how it is so remarkable that there are more real numbers in \( (0, 1) \) than there are natural numbers anywhere at all.
  • The Lebesgue measure of an isolated point is zero. Consequently, the Lebesgue measure of a countable number of isolated points is also zero. In particular, the Lebesgue measure of \( \mathbb{N} \), the natural numbers, is zero.
    • But what if we take an uncountable number of isolated points? Wait, is that even possible?
    • And what if we take “non-isolated” points, whatever that means?

Counting, uncounting, and dust, part five


Alright, so now we finally know that there isn’t one infinity any more. In fact, there is an infinite number of infinities, each infinitely larger than the one smaller than it, and so on upwards. Excelsior is a good motto for the infinitude of infinities (as it is for the Coat of Arms of the State of New York).



But we haven’t dealt with another problem: this way of measuring the size of a set just isn’t good enough for our purposes. We need something more refined, something that does distinguish between countable and uncountable while also capturing common-sense notions of the “length” of a line, the “area” of a sheet of paper, the “volume” of a hill, and so on. This is exactly what is studied in the branch of mathematics known as measure theory.


Saturday, May 26, 2012

The Arabic nominal system, the regular pattern

Let’s begin by looking at the case-endings for the regular (sālim, سالم) pattern. 


Singular


Dual
Definite Indefinite Construct Definite Indefinite Construct
marfū‘
-u
-un
-u
-āni
-āni
-ā
manṣūb
-a
-an
-a
-ayni
-ayni
-ay
majrūr
-i
-in
-i
-ayni
-ayni
-ay


This applies to all regular nouns and adjectives in the singular and the dual, whether they are masculine or feminine. Nouns like walad- and bint- and sayyāra(t)-; participles used participially, like kātib-; participles used nominally, like mubārā(t)-: all follow the same pattern.


What’s more, some kinds of masculine broken plurals also follow the sālim regular singular pattern of declension. Thus, the masculine word kuttāb (“(male) writers”), which is the broken plural of the word kātib- (a participle, but being used as a noun), follows the singular sālim declension. Just because a plural is formed in a broken manner does not automatically mean that its declension is also irregular.


There is also a sālim plural pattern, but this varies depending on gender. There is also a subtype of regular feminine nouns, which end in an ā, and which show slightly different endings. 


Plural—Animate Masculine
Definite
Indefinite
Construct



marfū‘
-ūna
-ūna
-ū



manṣūb
-īna
-īna
-ī



majrūr
-īna
-īna
-ī





This is the pattern that would be followed by the participle kātib- used participially (to describe a group of males that are currently engaged in a process of writing).


Plural—Feminine

Plural—Long ā Feminine
Definite
Indefinite
Construct
Definite
Indefinite
Construct
marfū‘
-ātu
-ātun
-ātu
-ayātu
-ayātun
-ayātu
manṣūb
-āti
-ātin
-āti
-ayāti
-ayātin
-ayātu
majrūr
-āti
-ātin
-āti
-ayāti
-ayātin
-ayāti


For example, the word sayyārat- in the singular declines as sayyār-āt- in the plural. The feminine ā word mubārā(t)- declines as mubār-ayāt-, etc.


More to follow on the “irregular” nominals.



Why pearls, and why strung at random?

In his translation of the famous "Turk of Shiraz" ghazal of Hafez into florid English, Sir William Jones, the philologist and Sanskrit scholar and polyglot extraordinaire, transformed the following couplet:

غزل گفتی و در سفتی بیا و خوش بخوان حافظ

که بر نظم تو افشاند فلک عقد ثریا را


into:

Go boldly forth, my simple lay,
Whose accents flow with artless ease,
Like orient pearls at random strung.

The "translation" is terribly inaccurate, but worse, the phrase is a gross misrepresentation of the highly structured organization of Persian poetry. Regardless, I picked it as the name of my blog for a number of reasons: 
1) I don't expect the ordering of my posts to follow any rhyme or reason
2) Since "at random strung" is a rather meaningless phrase, I decided to go with the longer but more pompous "pearls at random strung". I rest assured that my readers are unlikely to deduce from this an effort on my part to arrogate some of Hafez's peerless brilliance!

About Me

My photo
Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States
What is this life if, full of care,
We have no time to stand and stare.
—W.H. Davies, “Leisure”